Yesterday's News Today, people. So Denis Leary and Lenny Clark drop in on the announcers during a Red Sox game and proceed to
rough up Mel Gibson, keying off the presence and play of the Red Sox's Jewish first baseman. Seth Mnookin has the transcript (that's the link). Let's take a look, shall we?
***
Denis Leary: Now, Youkilis, is he a Greek kid?
Jerry Remy: No, I don’t think so.
Don Orsillo: I think he’s Jewish.
JR: He’s Jewish, yeah.
Lenny Clark: Really?
DL: that’s fantastic. That’s one bottle of whiskey away from being Irish Catholic. They got the Manischewitz, we got the Jamesons. It’s the same guilt, the same bad food. That’s fantastic, we got a Jewish first baseman! I didn’t know that. This is fabulous. …I’m so proud to have a Jewish first baseman. i didn’t even know!
[Godsbody: Oh, come now, Mr. Leary. You can do better than that. "One bottle of whiskey away from being Irish Catholic" is funny. "It's the same guilt" is funny. But the same bad food? You grew up Irish Catholic, so you know whereof you speak on the food thing, but I've had some fantastic meals in Jewish homes, eating traditional Jewish dishes. Gifeltefish aside, isn't there a stereotype about Jews eating well? And comparing Manischewitz with Jameson's may be some sort of blasphemy. I've heard Jews lament their days being forced to choke down that sweet, syrupy wine. But the Irish love their whiskey, no? (I know I do.) No one makes jokes about being forced to drink Jameson's - sometimes, they make jokes about how much they miss the stuff. I'm right with you on the similarities between Irish Catholics and Jews, but what came after was a swing and a miss.]
LC: I hope Mel Gibson doesn’t come into this park. We’ll run him out of here on a rail.
[Godsbody: Here's the thing. Everywhere I run into a story about this on the Internet, I read how Denis Leary laced into Mel Gibson. But from where I sit, it's Clark doing most of the attacking. Read on and see what you think.]
Mnookin: Jerry Remy begins hacking; it sounds as if he might be on the verge of losing a lung. Sean Casey hits a ball sharply in between first and second. Youkilis snares the ball from his knees and tosses to Curt Schilling for the out.
DL: Nice! Yeah, where’s Mel Gibson now! Where’s Mel Gibson now, huh? He’s in rehab! he’s in rehab and Youkilis has got first base, alright Mel! (Don Orsillo giggles uncontrollably.) You happy Braveheart, huh? You see that grab, Mel? I hope in rehab they’re showing replays of that. A Jewish first baseman makes the play, Mel Gibson! Good luck when you come out. Call Jeffrey Katzenberg and ask for a job when you get out. We’ll have a whole Jewish infield by the time he gets out. Bring back Sandy Koufax, Mel Gibson, huh? Braveheart, my ass. Thatta boy, Kev.
[Godsbody: I dunno. This reads more angry than funny. It's a fine line, making anger into humor. Most of the very best humor is born out of rage and suffering, I think. But this doesn't seem to sparkle much. After all, Gibson said that Jews were responsible for all the wars in the world, an accusation which was a long way from what Leary is implying here. Leary seems to be saying that Gibson doesn't think Jews are worth much - is Gibson supposed to be surprised that a Jew is a good ballplayer? Gibson, when drunk, suggested that Jews were capable of orchestrating events of massive historical consequence, of influencing the governments of multiple nations. If he really believes those things, then you don't have to tell Gibson that Jews are capable of highly skilled activity. I'm starting to think that people think this rant was hilarious just because it was ballsy. And it was only ballsy because of the context - this sort of thing isn't supposed to be the topic of conversation at a baseball game. Actually, it's not that ballsy to kick a man when he's down. It can be funny if done well, but it's not that ballsy. ]
LC: We should have Sandy Koufax pitch at Mel’s head.
[Godsbody: Whoa. This is what I mean about Clark being the one really going after Gibson.]
DL: That should be his community service, get in the box against Sandy Koufax. Guess who’s at first base? Kevin Youkilis!
[Godsbody: Better. Funnier than Clark's line, which is just mean.]
LC: Now what other Jewish players are there, because I’m not aware.
JR: Gabe Kapler, I think.
DL: Gabe Kapler! We got two Jews on this team, Mel! Where’s your father now, huh?
[Godsbody: Leary seems to being agreeing with Mark's notion that what came out of Gibson's mouth that night was, in some respect, the Voice of the Father.]
LC: How about that, Mel?
DL: Yeah. It feels good to get that out, didn’t it?
LC: We’ve got quite a team.
LC: Are we in trouble?
DL: No, we’re not in trouble. They don’t have TVs in rehab.
LC: Oh, I don’t care about Mel.
[snip]
DL: Boy, I’m so happy about that Kevin Youkilis thing.
LC: And Kapler! I didn’t even know!
DL: Well you know what’s gonna happen, Gibson’s gonna make amends: ‘Oh, I love the Red Sox! I love the first baseman!’ Oh yeah, sure you do. Sure you do Mel.
[Godsbody: Wow, Denis - for someone who once said, "I've been a Catholic or a lapsed Catholic all of my life" (according to
this site), you don't put much stock in contrition. But that's your call, I guess.]
LC: If I were Youkilis and Kapler I’d say, well, listen, am I in your next movie?
DL: Can we put some blue paint on our faces? Come on, Braveheart, huh? Look, I don’t know Mel. Why are we jumping all over him, you know what i mean? He had a little bit of tequila. You know those days. You were there.
[Godsbody: See what I mean? This is practically compassion for Gibson, unless he was being completely sarcastic. But I don't think he was, because suddenly, Clark gets defensive.]
LC: Now wait a minute, I never got personal. I never went with religion.
DL: No you didn’t. You always went with the face and the ugly and the fat and the nice dress and your girlfiend.
LC: It doesn’t matter what religion, you treat me good I’ll treat you better.
DL: That’s right.
Curt Schilling throws to Youkilis to pick Craig Monroe off of first.
DL: Ahhhh! Mel gibson take a look at that!
LC: Mel Gibson, eat your heart out! Youkilis tosses the ball to a fan in the stands. And look at that! The ball went to a fan! That’s more than Mel Gibson’s ever done!
[Godsbody: And you know that how?]
DO: See you later.
DL: Hope we didn’t get you in trouble.
DO: Thanks a lot, guys.
And…scene.
***
Here's the thing: I'm not a big Gibson fan. I wasn't a huge fan of The Passion of the Christ. I've even smiled at
a local radio station's dig at the man. But the praise I've seen heaped on this exchange just strikes me as weird.