-717273.jpg)
I love Whit Stillman's film
Metropolitan. (Lord help me, I had this poster on my dorm room wall freshman year.) And I'm not alone -
The Criterion Collection! But you know what
Metropolitan wasn't?
Commercially successful. I mean, wow - an Oscar nomination for Best Original Screenplay, and it pulled in only $3 million in theaters? (Of course, Box Office Mojo says that the film's widest release was only
five theaters - which means Cinemopolis on the Ithaca Commons, where I saw it, was in pretty rare company, and that the per-screen average was pretty darn impressive.)
I mention this because I was recently discussing my own little project,
Alphonse, with a friend who works in publishing. He said something about how, at the very least, my experience with trying to get the graphic novel made might teach me something about fitting my projects to a prospective audience.
I saw his point.
Alphonse has been, shall we say, slow to take off, despite receiving
a better-than-decent amount of attention. The attention itself may give some indication as to why that is. The comments at
The Awl,
Jezebel, and
Broadsheet made it clear that the concept was more than a little radioactive - some people clued in to the fact that a revenge-minded fetus wasn't exactly the most sympathetic character, but still weren't able to imagine that what I was trying to make was anything other than propaganda. They still weren't able to discuss a work of art about abortion that explored the moral anxiety surrounding the fetus without entering into a political argument.
Tracy Clark-Flory at
Broadsheet, for example, decided that
Alphonse was "yet one more attempt to argue for the personhood of the fetus by literally giving it a voice." She decided that I had created a caricature of my own moral viewpoint.
To the latter claim, I say - damn straight. Alphonse is absolutely a caricature. That is, he is a gross exaggeration - a fetus whose personhood is so manifest that he can walk and talk and think and fight. But Clark-Flory was dead wrong about the
purpose of that exaggeration.
Alphonse is not arguing for the personhood of the fetus by literally giving it a voice. It's not arguing for anything at all. It's telling a story. There's a difference. As I said at the end of my essay at
The Awl, "I was trying to make a work of art (however minor) that would do some of the things that art does - reflect experience, engage imagination, and just maybe, enlarge perspective."
Which brings me to problem number two:
it's not propaganda. Folks looking for something that's straightforwardly "Yay for our side, boo for their side!" are going to be disappointed. So who's my audience?
Fair question. Maybe it's just me and a curious few. But my friend in publishing is - sadly - mistaken. Two issues in, I haven't learned anything about fitting my projects to my prospective audience. I'm still begging, still trying to finish the story.
Metropolitan was worth it, even at five screens and three million. I think
Alphonse is worth it, too.
Which brings me, at long last, to my point. The ridiculous generosity of both friends and strangers is about to bump my
Kickstarter fund for Issue Three from $600 to $1600. Still shy of halfway to my goal of $4000, but gosh-all, it's amazing. As of tomorrow, I will have twenty days left to raise the rest. I had pretty much given up. Now, I'm daring to hope again.
So if you're still reading by this point, and if you're at all intrigued, please consider helping out. If you've already donated, maybe forward this post on to a friend. If you blog or Tumble or tweet, maybe consider tossing me a link. I've gotten this far. I don't want to quit before it's over. Thank you for your time and consideration.